Save Pin
This savory Cajun seafood pot pie mixes Southern goodness with a fun kick. It uses simple stuff you can find at any grocery store, yet it turns out so eye-catching. Each forkful is packed with crawfish, crab, and shrimp all swimming in a flavorful creamy sauce and sealed in a golden crust. When I want to wow my gang and keep them happy, this is my go-to comfort food.
I first whipped this up on a stormy evening because I needed some cozy food. Now it's our standby when the crew wants some Louisiana-style comfort at home.
Hearty Ingredients
- Seafood medley (shrimp, crawfish, crab): They each bring a little something—sweet, briny, perfectly tender. Just get what’s freshest or thaw frozen right before starting.
- Chopped onions: Give everything a mellow sweetness and that familiar Cajun taste. Heavy onions are usually freshest.
- Chopped celery: Crunchy and gives off a gentle aroma. Pick stalks that are stiff and leafy.
- Chopped bell peppers: Splash in a little color and mild sweet flavor. Pick ones that are shiny and solid.
- Fresh garlic (minced): Instantly wakes up those flavors. Use plump cloves that haven't started sprouting.
- Butter: Richness in every bite plus it starts the roux. Unsalted butter makes it easier to adjust salt later.
- All-purpose flour: Gets the sauce nice and thick. Sift it if it seems lumpy to avoid surprises later.
- Seafood broth: Brings everything together with soothing flavor. Homemade’s great, but store bought is just fine too.
- Heavy cream: Makes your filling extra smooth. Try to grab one at 36% fat for that silky finish.
- Cajun seasoning: Adds tons of smoke and heat. Look for blends with paprika, oregano, thyme, garlic, and a little kick from cayenne so it tastes legit.
- Pie dough: Gives you that irresistible golden top and bottom. Pick up a quality double crust pack or DIY it to show off.
Easy Step-by-Step Directions
- Pop It in the Oven:
- Stick the filled and sealed pie in a preheated oven at 375 degrees. Bake until the top turns golden brown, about 30–35 minutes. If you see the edges getting dark fast, wrap just the rim with foil so it doesn’t burn.
- Build the Pie:
- Lay out the bottom crust in a 9-inch pie dish. Press into the sides. Pour in your hot filling and smooth it out. Put the second crust on top. Pinch the edges to close it up, then cut a few slits on the top so steam can escape.
- Add Seafood & Spice:
- Toss in the shrimp, crab, crawfish, plus Cajun seasoning. Simmer everything together about five minutes, just until the seafood is opaque and pink. Don’t let it cook too long so it keeps its tender bite.
- Make the Creamy Base:
- Pour in seafood broth slowly, whisking as you go to keep it smooth. Once combined, add the cream. Keep stirring while it thickens for about five minutes. You want it velvety, not runny.
- Make That Roux:
- Stir the flour into your cooked veggies. Keep moving everything around 3–4 minutes until it smells a bit nutty and turns pale golden. This is what helps thicken the mix later.
- Sizzle the Veggies:
- Toss onions, peppers, and celery into melted butter in a big skillet over medium. Let them cook, stirring so nothing sticks, for eight minutes—just until they're soft and see-through but not brown.
Save Pin
How to Store Leftovers
After it cools off, tuck the pie in the fridge, covered. It’ll be good for three days. For stashing longer, wrap individual slices in some foil and freeze them. When you want some, heat them up straight from thawed at 350 degrees until they’re hot and crisp again.
Swap Options
If you can’t grab crawfish or crab, scallops or firm white fish work great. Want a blast of smokiness? Sprinkle in some chopped smoked sausage. Try milk instead of cream if you want to lighten it up, but cut back a bit so the filling stays creamy.
How to Serve It
I usually dish this up with a zippy green salad drizzled in lemony vinaigrette. Sometimes I leave out hot sauce and some tart pickles so everyone can doctor their plate. A big piece of cornbread on the side is always a hit too.
Save Pin
Cajun Cooking Vibes
Louisiana’s food scene shines thanks to all the seafood you’ll find there. Cajun cooking brings together French ideas and loads of Southern staples. This dish puts a modern spin on those classic, saucy stews and hand pies My crew always begs for a second helping.
Common Recipe Questions
- → Which seafood tastes best here?
Using shrimp, crab, and crawfish gives the most layered flavor, but scallops or solid white fish work well, too—just go with what you like or can find.
- → Is it super spicy?
You’ll get some warmth from the Cajun mix, but you’re in control—use a little or a lot to make it as hot or mild as you want.
- → Should I go for homemade dough, or is store-bought okay?
You can pick either kind—use what’s in the fridge or whip some up from scratch. Both get crisp if handled right.
- → How do I keep the top nice and crisp?
Let the top brown up deep in the oven and wait a bit before slicing. Getting the pan hot before filling it keeps the bottom from getting mushy, too.
- → What’s good to eat with this?
Try it with some greens, warm cornbread, or soft okra—these sides take the edge off the rich filling and taste great together.