Save Pin
Bring a warm date night vibe home with this Mushroom Fettuccine Alfredo Our favorite comfort dish is all about tender noodles and rich creamy mushroom sauce It feels fancy but is honestly super chill to make If you're into cozy classics with a little extra oomph get ready to put this pasta into your dinner line up
This started as a Friday night experiment when the fridge was bare and we wanted something good The first bite had us hooked Now we make it all the time
Ingredients
- Salt and pepper: You want to season everything as you cook Taste as you go for best results
- Fresh oregano: Lively and a bit spicy Boosts flavor Use fresh if possible but dried works too
- Fresh thyme leaves: Fragrant and lemony Makes things pop Go for vibrant looking leaves
- Parmesan cheese: Nutty, creamy, and sharp Grab a block and shred it yourself for meltiness
- Skim milk: Lighter but still creamy Go fat free to keep it light or 2 percent if you want extra smoothness
- Vegetable broth: Lends a bit of depth to the sauce Pick low sodium if you want to control your salt
- White wine or white wine vinegar: Adds zing Crisp white is awesome here
- All purpose flour: Helps the sauce get cozy and thick Unbleached has a cleaner flavor
- Unsalted butter: For richness and melt Adjust your salt after
- Extra virgin olive oil: For sautéing and flavor Try to snag cold pressed
- Garlic: You want it fresh It brings a toasty deep flavor
- Cremini mushrooms: Earthy, meaty flavor Go for dry sturdy caps
- Fettuccine pasta: Bronze cut if you can for the best sauce grip
Step by Step Instructions
- Combine Everything and Plate:
- Drop the drained pasta right into your skillet with that dreamy sauce Stir it until the noodles are slick If it's feeling stiff, splash in that saved pasta water Sprinkle on fresh herbs and dish it up while hot
- Add Cheese and Herbs:
- Turn down the heat Toss in parmesan cheese Stir until smooth and glossy and melty Next, add your oregano and thyme Season well with salt and pepper before you taste it
- Let the Sauce Thicken Up:
- Let the sauce simmer on medium low for three or four minutes Keep stirring so nothing burns You want it a bit thicker now
- Make It Creamy:
- Slowly add in veggie broth while you keep stirring Then pour in the milk next Keep it moving until it looks luxuriously smooth
- Start the Alfredo Base:
- Drop in your last two tablespoons of butter Stir to melt Sprinkle on flour and mix it all together Keep going for about two minutes so the flour really cooks in
- Get Flavor Going with Garlic and Wine:
- Stir in minced garlic Let it cook just till it gets that amazing smell Pour in the wine Scrape the pan so any tasty brown bits join the party
- Cook the Mushrooms:
- Heat oil plus a tablespoon of butter in a big pan over medium Add those sliced mushrooms Let them sauté for five minutes stirring now and then until soft and juicy
- Make the Pasta:
- Bring water to a boil and cook fettuccine till it's just right Remember to save a little cooking water before you drain
Save Pin
It's wild how well parmesan melts into every batch The sauce gets so silky My kid always begs to be the one to mix in the cheese—his glasses fog up every single time And even the pickiest folks come back for seconds
Storage Tips
Store leftovers in a lidded container in the fridge for up to three days When it's time to eat again gently reheat it on the stove with some milk or pasta water to get the creaminess back Just break apart any stuck pasta and mix it until smooth
Ingredient Substitutions
No cremini? Go with baby bella or plain button mushrooms You want it dairy free? Try oat milk for skim and swap parmesan for nutritional yeast For a veggie boost toss in spinach or a handful of peas at the end
Save Pin
Serving Suggestions
This pasta stands up all by itself But if you're feeling extra serve it with a bright green salad and lemony dressing or some warm garlic bread A little more parmesan or black pepper on top gives it that special something
Cultural Context
Classic fettuccine Alfredo started out in Rome about a century ago with just buttered noodles for an easy meal Americans started adding cheese and cream to blend up a richer vibe This mushroom spin keeps the Italian roots but brings even bigger flavors and heartier texture
Common Recipe Questions
- → Is it okay to swap out the mushrooms?
For sure! Cremini’s a solid pick, but swap in white button, shiitake, or toss in wild mushrooms if you want to mix things up.
- → Does this meal already count as vegetarian?
Yep! It’s set up that way—uses veggie broth and skips meat. Just double-check your parmesan is the kind without animal stuff, since some use rennet.
- → What’s the best way to change up the sauce thickness?
Let it simmer longer if you want it extra thick before mixing with the pasta. For a thinner vibe, splash in a bit of pasta water as you toss everything together.
- → Can I swap the white wine for something else?
Not a fan of wine? Try a shot of white wine vinegar or more veggie broth for that bright kick in the sauce instead.
- → Can I make this ahead of time?
This one’s tastiest right after you cook it. But if you have leftovers, warm it gently with a bit of extra milk or broth to bring back that creamy feel.
- → What would go well on the side?
Try adding a crisp salad or some roasted veggies for balance. Honestly, garlic bread also soaks up that sauce like a champ.