Comforting Slow Cooker Steak Cheddar Potatoes

Coming home to the dreamy smell of melty cheese and seared steak just makes any day better. With this slow cooker steak and cheddar potato bake, you'll get maximum comfort with almost zero effort. Tender potatoes, juicy steak pieces, and loads of cheddar come together in layers that are straight-up soul-warming.

This is my go-to for family parties because everybody grabs seconds. When I made it the first time, my youngest told me it was way better than eating out and begged for leftovers in his lunchbox.

Irresistible Ingredients

• Sirloin or ribeye steak cubes: They’re full of flavor and cook up juicy Pick a cut with some fat in it for the best texture
• Russet or Yukon Gold potatoes: Both kinds stay creamy after hours in the slow cooker Yukon is extra buttery
• Sharp cheddar cheese: Freshly shredded is smooth and tastes richer than the bagged kind Either yellow or white cheddar works if it’s aged
• Heavy cream: It brings a silky sauce together Use cream that smells and tastes fresh
• Beef broth: Makes the whole bake taste meaty Try low sodium for more control
• Onion: Chopped small for sweetness and a little bite Firm onions with dry skin are best
• Garlic: Gives a kick of flavor and adds to the aroma Fresh garlic is the way to go
• Butter: Adds flavor to the steak when browning and makes everything a little cozier Unsalted is easiest
• Smoked paprika: Gives smoky flavor plus a pop of color Try Spanish paprika for big taste
• Black pepper: Wakes up all the flavors A few twists of the pepper grinder is perfect
• Salt: Makes everything pop Kosher salt sprinkles more evenly

Simple Step Guide

Brown the Steak

Melt a bit of butter in your skillet over medium-high Add steak that’s been hit with salt, pepper, and paprika Sear on every side for about five minutes so a deep crust forms The browning brings out amazing flavor

Build the Layers

Lay half your potatoes at the bottom of the slow cooker, overlapping for even cooking Throw in half the onion and garlic Next pile on all the browned steak Top with the rest of the potatoes, then the last of the onion and garlic Layering like this gives flavor in every bite

Add Creaminess

Drizzle in the cream and beef broth over everything If you want, toss in another shake of salt and pepper This turns all those layers into rich yumminess

Cheddar Finish

Spread shredded cheddar right on top so it covers the whole surface The top will turn cheesy and a little crispy as it cooks

Let It Slow Cook

Pop the lid on and cook six to eight hours on low or three to four on high Potatoes should soften up and cheese should get a little crusty on the edges Give it ten minutes to cool so the sauce gets thick

Save Pin

I’m obsessed with the smoked paprika because I remember my grandma’s kitchen It was her secret for making steak extra special The smoky touch reminds me of our long Sunday dinners together

Smart Storage

Pop leftovers in the fridge in a sealed container for up to three days Let it cool a bit first so moisture doesn’t mess things up Want to freeze? Scoop into single portions so it’s easy to reheat later Bake it in the oven with foil on top to keep it from drying out

Swap Ideas

No sirloin or ribeye? Chuck steak or stew beef gets the job done and keeps it cheap Mix in Monterey Jack for oven pull-apart cheese vibes If you’re looking to lighten things up use half and half, low fat cheese, and even sub sweet potatoes for a different twist and a pop of color

Save Pin

Serving Up

This dish is hearty enough solo but is even better with something fresh like a crisp green salad or roasted brussels sprouts For a major treat top with chopped chives or a spoonful of sour cream Grab some toasty bread for the ultimate comfort dinner

Food Story and Traditions

Potato bakes are found everywhere because they’re budget-friendly and satisfying Mixing steak and potatoes in one pot feels both classic and homey—a bit like old-school au gratin gone modern Slow cookers got huge in the ’70s because they let busy families sit down to hot home-cooked meals This dish keeps that tradition alive but throws in extra cheese for fun

Common Recipe Questions

→ Could I swap in a different kind of beef?

Sure thing, try stew meat or chuck if that’s what you have. Just give those tougher cuts more time in the slow cooker so they soften right up.

→ Do the potatoes need peeling first?

If you like smooth bites, peel ‘em. Keep the skins on for more texture and nutrition. Totally up to you—both ways taste good.

→ What stops it from turning out too watery?

Go for russet potatoes and avoid rinsing them. Cut everything evenly, and don’t add extra liquid unless you want it a bit saucier.

→ Is it okay to put this together in advance?

Absolutely! Stack up all the layers the night before, pop the dish in the fridge, and just start the slow cooker in the morning when you’re ready.

→ How do I bump up the flavor?

Toss in some thyme or rosemary if you’ve got them. Sprinkle chopped chives or green onions on top when it’s done for a fresh kick.

→ What should I serve on the side?

A crisp salad, some crunchy bread, or roasted veggies go great with this hearty main. Keep it simple and filling.