Save Pin
This Monterey chicken spaghetti is everything I want in a cozy meal. It’s got stretchy cheese, soft pasta, hearty bits of chicken, and a full-flavored sauce. Super simple to throw together during the week and it really hits the spot every time.
The very first time I whipped up this comfort dish, my buddies demolished the whole thing at movie night. They all wanted second helpings and the secret.
Tasty Ingredients
- Fresh parsley: brings a pop of color and freshness. Go for flat leaf for a nice texture.
- Salt and black pepper: make everything else shine. Crack them fresh for max flavor.
- Italian seasoning: gives zesty herby punch. Get a mix that’s got enough basil, thyme, and oregano for that balance.
- Paprika: a sprinkle lifts up color and gives a soft smoky note. Sweet paprika works best.
- Butter: makes things richer and helps the onions cook down. Unsalted lets you handle the salt yourself.
- Olive oil: adds a hint of flavor and helps everything brown. Extra virgin cold-pressed is best if you can swing it.
- Heavy cream: thickens up your sauce till it’s super creamy. Use freshly opened for a lush finish.
- Chicken broth: makes everything taste deeper. Go low sodium so you’re in control of the saltiness.
- Fresh garlic: boosts the aroma. Pick hefty firm cloves.
- Yellow onion: brings sweetness. Look for a firm one with smooth skin.
- Monterey Jack cheese: gives that gooey, melty magic. Buy a block so you can shred it fresh.
- Boneless skinless chicken breasts: juicy and soaks up all the flavor. Want them firm and pink with zero weird spots.
- Spaghetti: aim for just tender, not mushy. Go for bronze-cut if you see it, grabs the sauce like a champ.
Easy-To-Follow Steps
- Garnish and Serve:
- Chop up some fresh parsley and sprinkle it on top at the end. It brightens up the whole plate. Serve right away to keep everything creamy and hot.
- Finish With Cheese:
- After mixing everything, pile the Monterey Jack over the top, cover the pan, and let it chill for a couple minutes till the cheese melts all gooey over everything.
- Combine Pasta Chicken and Sauce:
- Take the cooked pasta and browned chicken, add them to your skillet, then use tongs to mix it all so the sauce gets everywhere.
- Build the Sauce:
- Pour in your broth and cream next. Stir gently while it bubbles on low for about five minutes to thicken up. Keep an eye so nothing sticks.
- Sauté the Aromatics:
- In the same skillet, toss in the butter. Add in the chopped onions and let them go soft, just a few minutes, no browning. Toss in the garlic for around thirty seconds to get it nice and fragrant.
- Cook the Chicken:
- Heat olive oil in a big skillet on medium. Toss chicken bits in paprika, Italian herbs, salt, and pepper. Sear all sides for about seven minutes till golden and cooked through. Take them out and cover to keep juicy.
- Cook the Spaghetti:
- Fill up a big pot with salted water; when it boils, toss in the spaghetti and cook till it’s just underdone. Drain and set aside so it doesn’t get mushy in the sauce.
- Prep the Ingredients:
- Knock out all your prepping at the start. Cut the chicken, shred the cheese, dice the onion, and mince that garlic. Makes life way easier as you cook.
Save Pin
Honestly, my favorite part is the way the gooey Monterey Jack cheese stretches with every forkful. My sister and I used to sneak hunks of it straight from the pan on pasta nights. Still brings me back to those fun family dinners.
Keeping It Fresh
Let your leftovers cool, then stash them covered in the fridge for up to three days. Warm it gently on the stove with a splash of cream or broth to keep that sauce nice and loose. Skip the microwave if you can — melted cheese turns rubbery fast.
Swap Outs
No Monterey Jack? Try some Colby or mozzarella instead. Want to lighten it up? Use half and half for the cream. You can toss in cooked turkey or rotisserie chicken too — works just fine.
Ways to Serve
Add some fresh crunch with a green salad or throw in a side of broccoli. Sprinkle on red pepper flakes or some crispy breadcrumbs for extra texture. Let folks add more cheese if they want it over the top.
Save Pin
Origin or Backstory
This kind of dish is inspired by classic American bakes that celebrate gooey cheese over pasta. Monterey Jack hails from California and melts like a dream, making it a top pick for anything creamy and bubbly straight from the oven.
Common Recipe Questions
- → What can I sub for Monterey Jack if I don't have any?
Sure thing! Grab cheddar, mozzarella, or any gooey cheese you have handy. They all melt great.
- → What's a good way to sneak in more veggies?
Try adding roasted broccoli, or toss in some mushrooms, peppers, or spinach when you cook the onions for a boost of taste and color.
- → How do I stop the chicken from getting tough?
Slice chicken into even chunks and cook until just done—no longer. Once they look golden and cooked through, move them out of the pan before you finish up the sauce.
- → What's the trick for non-mushy spaghetti?
Boil the noodles until they're al dente. Mix them with the sauce right before you eat, so they stay firm and don't overdo it.
- → Best way to save and heat up leftovers?
Pop leftovers in a sealed container in your fridge—good for up to three days. Warm them back up on low and add a splash of cream or broth to keep things creamy.
- → How can I turn up the heat in this dish?
Easy! Throw in cayenne or some chili flakes while cooking if you like a spicy kick.