Save Pin
Nothing beats this homemade chicken pot pie when you're craving comfort food! I've whipped this up countless times over the years, and it always brings everyone rushing to the table. There's something magical about the mix of that crispy, rich crust and the smooth chicken mixture that takes you right back to those warm, cozy feelings.
The first time I cooked this pot pie was during a brutal cold snap when we couldn't leave the house for days. The smell wrapped our home in coziness, and these days my kids constantly ask for it as their weekend treat.
Ingredients
- For the chicken pot pie crust:
- All purpose flour: Gives your crust that perfect flaky structure
- Sugar: Brings a hint of sweetness to balance the savory stuff inside
- Cold unsalted butter: The key to getting those wonderful flaky bits
- Buttermilk: Adds a little tang and makes the crust extra soft
- Cold water: Brings everything together without making the dough tough
- Egg wash: Gives you that gorgeous golden top
- For the pot pie filling:
- Unsalted butter: Forms the foundation for a tasty, thick base
- Onion, carrots, and celery: Make up the tasty foundation of your filling
- Fresh garlic: Brings a punch of flavor you can't get from powder
- Flour: Helps thicken up your sauce to the perfect consistency
- Fresh herbs: Take your pot pie from basic to amazing
- Chicken broth: Adds rich flavor throughout the sauce
- Heavy cream: Makes everything deliciously smooth and rich
- Shredded chicken or turkey: Turns this into a filling, wonderful meal
- Frozen peas: Add a pop of color, sweetness, and nice texture
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Make the pie crust:
- Mix your dry stuff in a big bowl, then work in the cold butter chunks by folding them into thin layers with the flour mix. This trick gives you those amazing flaky bits that make homemade so much better than store-bought. Let it cool for 15 minutes to keep the butter from melting, then pour in buttermilk and shape into two disks before putting in the fridge.
- Prepare the filling:
- Heat butter in a big pan over medium-high heat, then toss in your veggies and cook them until soft, around 5 to 7 minutes. You want them tender but not browned. Make your sauce by slowly mixing in flour and spices followed by the wet ingredients, making sure you don't get any clumps. Stirring constantly stops your sauce from getting lumpy later. Let it bubble until thick, then gently stir in your chicken and peas.
- Assemble the pie:
- Roll your first cold dough disk into a 12-inch circle about 1/4 inch thick on a lightly floured counter. Getting the thickness right matters a lot – too skinny and it'll break, too chunky and it won't cook right. Carefully lift it into your pie dish and pour in your filling. Roll the second disk and lay it on top, then trim and pinch the edges together however you like.
- Bake to golden perfection:
- Brush beaten egg all over the top to make it shiny and golden when baked. Cut a few small holes in the top so steam can escape while cooking. These little vents stop your filling from bubbling over and making your oven messy. Bake at 400°F for 45 minutes, and use something to cover the edges if they're getting too dark.
Save Pin
The one thing that really changes this recipe is using fresh thyme. I grow mine at home, and when it hits the hot mixture, the smell reminds me of my grandma, who taught me about pie crusts when I was barely tall enough to see over the kitchen counter. She always told me that taking your time was the real secret to any good pie.
Make Ahead Options
This pot pie works great for planning ahead. You can cook the filling up to two days early and keep it in the fridge. The dough can also be made beforehand and kept cold for up to three days or frozen for up to three months. When you're ready to cook, just put everything together as normal and add around 5 to 10 extra minutes to your baking time if you're starting with cold ingredients.
Substitution Ideas
You can switch things up easily with this dish. Use turkey instead of chicken after Thanksgiving or try adding leftover holiday ham for something different. If you don't eat meat, just throw in more veggies like mushrooms, potatoes, and green beans, plus extra seasonings. Don't do dairy? Coconut cream works instead of heavy cream and gives a nice but different taste. You can use gluten-free flour mixes for both parts of the recipe, though it might feel a bit different in your mouth.
Save Pin
Serving Suggestions
Pair this pot pie with an easy green salad with light dressing to balance out the richness. For a truly comforting meal, add some cranberry sauce on the side, which brings a sweet and tangy contrast that goes really well with the savory flavors. When serving for a special occasion, try using individual small dishes for a fancy look that also makes serving quicker.
The History Behind Chicken Pot Pie
People have been eating pot pies for hundreds of years, with versions showing up in ancient Roman cookbooks and medieval European kitchens. The American version we enjoy today came from meat pies that English settlers brought over. At first, these pies were just a smart way to stretch leftover meat to feed more people. The mix of chicken, veggies, and gravy wrapped in pastry became super popular in the American South and Pennsylvania Dutch areas, where they really know their comfort food.
Common Recipe Questions
- → Is it okay to use store-bought rotisserie chicken?
For sure! A rotisserie chicken works wonders in this recipe. It cuts down on cooking time and makes prep easier while adding great taste.
- → Can I make this ahead and freeze it?
You bet! Just put everything together, wrap it up tight, and pop it in the freezer. When you're hungry, cook it frozen—just add about 10-15 extra minutes to the baking time.
- → Will pre-made pie crust work for this recipe?
Definitely! Ready-made crusts save tons of time. But if you've got a few extra minutes, making your own gives you that extra-flaky texture and richer taste.
- → What other veggies can I throw in?
Mix it up with mushrooms, sweet corn, fresh green beans, or chunky potatoes—whatever you like best or have sitting in your fridge.
- → How do I keep the edges from getting too brown?
Just grab some foil and wrap it around the edges if they start looking too dark, or use a pie shield if you've got one handy.