Save Pin
Everything happens in one pan with this rich, comfy Spinach and Mushroom Orzo. It’s got risotto vibes but keeps things easy with orzo pasta and quick cooking. Perfect when you crave some comfort and don't feel like making a bunch of dirty dishes. This meal stands on its own if you don’t eat meat but also slides right in next to roast chicken or shrimp if you want extra protein.
When I tried this for the first time, I couldn’t believe how smooth and tasty it came out. Even my pickiest kid—who says mushrooms are their enemy—was chasing every bite.
Tasty Ingredients
- Fresh spinach: Tosses in a burst of color and nutrients. Baby varieties wilt quick and taste sweet. Fresh is best here
- Heavy cream: Turns everything into a lush, velvety sauce. Skip the half-and-half, real cream’s the move
- Red pepper flakes: For a gentle kick and a bit of color—add just before eating
- Paprika: Gives an earthy undertone and a beautiful ruby hue. Try smoked paprika for a bigger punch
- Salt and black pepper: Brings out all the flavors. Taste and add more as you go
- Italian herbs or Provencal blend: Makes the dish taste fancy with hints of thyme, oregano, and rosemary. Any dried mix works
- Garlic, fresh: Starts the base. Grate it or chop it tiny for the best flavor
- Chicken broth or stock: Adds loads of flavor. I go low sodium because it’s easier to control saltiness
- Orzo pasta: Rice-shaped, cooks fast, and soaks up all the saucy goodness
- Olive oil: Kicks up the richness and helps mushrooms brown. Extra virgin gives the best flavor
- Baby bella or cremini mushrooms: Hold their shape and have that deep, yummy savoriness. Look for ones that aren’t bruised or damp
Easy Step-by-Step
- Add Back the Mushrooms:
- Stir in the saved mushrooms, taste, and adjust with salt or pepper if it needs it. Sprinkle red pepper flakes over the top if you like a little heat.
- Make Everything Creamy:
- Pour in the cream, turn the heat to just low, and gently mix until it all comes together. Don’t let it start to bubble, just warm it through.
- Spinach Wilting Time:
- Mix in the spinach a few minutes before the orzo is finished. The warmth will soften it quick.
- Let Orzo Soak Up Liquid:
- Turn the heat down, keep stirring so nothing sticks, and cook the orzo till there’s just enough liquid left and it’s tender, maybe five to ten minutes.
- Add Orzo and Flavor:
- Stir the orzo, herbs, broth, seasonings, and garlic into the mushrooms. Give it a good mix and bring to a strong simmer.
- Start with Mushrooms:
- Warm up oil in a big skillet. Throw in sliced mushrooms, lots of salt and pepper. Let them cook till brown and soft, then scoop some out and save those for later.
Save Pin
What I love most is how the broth makes the orzo super silky and tasty. The first time I cooked this for a birthday, even folks who said, 'Spinach? No thanks,' came back for seconds.
Saving Leftovers
Keep any extras in a container with a tight lid and stash it in the fridge for up to three days. It’ll get thicker the longer it sits, but a splash of milk or broth when heating it up brings back that creamy texture. Warm it gently either on the stove—low and slow—or zap it in the microwave in short bursts.
Swap-Out Ideas
For a totally vegetarian version, swap the chicken broth for veggie broth. If you’re out of cream, full fat coconut milk does the trick—with just a slight flavor shift. Got kale or chard instead of spinach? Those work, just let them cook a bit longer to soften.
Save Pin
How to Serve It
This one’s a meal all by itself, but I love it with roasted veggies or a big salad. If you want something heartier, top with shrimp, chicken, or baked fish. And definitely grab some crunchy bread—perfect for dunking up any sauce left on your plate.
Backstory and Traditions
Orzo looks a lot like rice but it’s actually a pasta, super popular in Italian and Greek dishes. It’s awesome at soaking up flavors in soups and pilaf. Creamy orzo is a quicker, simpler stand-in for risotto—awesome for hectic weeknights.
Common Recipe Questions
- → What keeps orzo from sticking when I cook it?
Just give it a good stir now and then as it cooks, especially when the broth’s getting low. Keep the stove at a gentle medium-low and make sure you don’t let the pan dry out.
- → Can I try other mushrooms here?
For sure. Use baby bellas, crimini, or just plain button mushrooms—whatever you’re into works fine. Mix it up to suit your taste.
- → How do I make this totally meat-free?
Just swap out chicken broth for veggie broth. You’ll still get awesome depth of flavor with zero meat involved.
- → Which protein goes best with spinach mushroom orzo?
Cook up some shrimp, toss in grilled chicken, or add golden tofu on top—any of these make it even heartier and work really well with the creamy flavors.
- → Any tips for saving and reheating extras?
Pop leftovers in a sealed container in your fridge. They’ll be good for about three days. When you want them again, warm gently on the stove with a splash of broth or cream to keep things nice and smooth.