Save Pin
This is my favorite quick fix when I’m craving something hearty but don’t want to fill every pepper. You get all the comforting goodness of stuffed peppers—juicy ground meat, soft rice, colorful peppers, tangy tomatoes, and melty cheese all cuddled up together in one pot. It’s like the best part of stuffed peppers but so much less work.
When the temperatures dropped, this was the meal I reached for—it turned my kitchen into the coziest spot. Now, my family fights over the leftovers. That’s how you know it’s good.
Tasty Ingredients
- Yellow onion: Adds a mellow sweetness as it cooks. Use a solid one—skip any with sprouts.
- Shredded cheddar cheese: Melts nicely. For an extra creamy texture, grate it yourself.
- Italian seasoning: Brings those familiar herby flavors. Go for blends with thyme, oregano, and basil.
- Garlic: Ramps up the flavor. Choose fresh, firm cloves—no green centers.
- Frozen chopped spinach: Packs in color, nutrition, and bulk. Thaw it and wring out extra water to keep things from getting soggy.
- Red and green bell peppers: Give a sweet bite and crunch. Pick shiny, sturdy peppers.
- Uncooked brown rice: Makes the dish extra toothsome. Long grain is best if you can find it.
- Ground cumin: Lends a deep earthy taste. Use freshly ground for the most pop.
- Kosher salt: Pulls the flavors together. Fine grains work for even seasoning.
- Worcestershire sauce: Adds that savory kick. Avoid ones that are overly sugary.
- Ground turkey or chicken or lean ground beef: All work for your protein hit—grab whichever you like most.
- Fresh cilantro or parsley and Greek yogurt for finishing: Toss them on top for a bright herby finish and a cool hit.
- No salt added tomato sauce: Cuts back on saltiness. Pick one with no sugar sneaked in.
- Shredded pepper jack cheese or Monterey Jack or mozzarella: Adds some gooeyness and gentle heat. Use whatever’s freshest.
- Ground pepper: Wakes up the whole dish. Fresh cracked is always more zingy.
- Fire-roasted diced tomatoes (with juice): Bring a sweet, smoky note. Make sure they smell bright, not metallic.
- Extra virgin olive oil: Deepens flavor and helps brown everything. The better the oil, the tastier your dish.
- Water: For cooking the rice and making everything come together.
Easy Instructions
- Start Melting the Cheese:
- As soon as your pot’s off the burner, sprinkle your cheeses over everything and cover it up. Let it rest about ten minutes until melty and a bit thicker.
- Add and Soften the Veggies:
- Mix in the thawed spinach, breaking it up with a fork, and toss in the bell peppers. Give everything a good stir so the veggies get coated and look bright.
- Sprinkle Garnishes and Serve Up:
- Spoon into bowls. Top with whatever fresh herbs you have and a spoon of Greek yogurt—totally ups the flavor.
- Get That Golden Cheese (Optional):
- If you love gooey tops, pop the uncovered pot under your broiler for a minute or two. Keep watch—the cheese should go bubbly and golden, not burnt.
- Cook Everything Together:
- Pour in water, tomatoes, the tomato sauce, Worcestershire, and your uncooked rice. Stir it up so the rice gets fully wet, then turn up the heat until it boils. Drop to a simmer, cover, and leave it for about half an hour.
- Finish Rice:
- Pop the lid off, stir so nothing sticks, then cover back up and let it keep going for another 10-15 minutes. Taste a bite—the rice is ready when it’s soft but a little chewy.
- Sizzle the Meat:
- Heat olive oil in a big Dutch oven on medium high. Add your meat and onion once the oil flashes. Crumble and stir until meat browns and onion goes see-through, about 7 minutes. This makes the base tasty.
- Wake Up Spices:
- Dump in Italian seasoning, cumin, salt, pepper, and minced garlic. Give it all a quick toss for about a minute. Garlic should only just start smelling good here, not get brown.
Save Pin
I get a real kick out of tossing in homegrown red bell peppers when I have them on hand. One time, my kid picked out every single red pepper chunk and gobbled those up first. Ever since, I always throw in some extra for her.
How to Store Leftovers
Let it cool before you stash it away. Put the leftovers in a tight-lid container and keep it in the fridge for four days tops. It heats up super fast in the microwave or on the stovetop. To freeze, split into meal-sized batches in freezer-safe containers. Good for three months. Defrost in the fridge overnight, then warm up before digging in.
Swap Options
No brown rice on hand? White rice totally works, but it’ll cook faster, so just check it sooner. No spinach? Use kale or collards. Any ground meat does the trick. Want things milder? Swap in mozzarella for the cheese. And if you’re out of Worcestershire, a splash of soy sauce gets the job done.
Serving Ideas
This dish stands alone just fine, but tossing together a crisp salad or ripping up some crusty bread on the side is always welcome. It packs up well—great for a thermos lunch at work or school. A drizzle of hot sauce wakes things up if you want a bit of fire.
Save Pin
Origin Story and Traditions
Stuffed peppers are big in Mediterranean, Eastern European, and Latin American kitchens—each spot throws in its favorite spices, grains, and meats. This all-in-one version comes from classic American cooking, where quick, family-style meals are a lifesaver, but you still want big, bold flavors.
Common Recipe Questions
- → Is there a type of ground meat that works best here?
Use ground turkey, chicken, or beef. Pick whatever you like best or what you've got hanging out in your fridge.
- → Can I swap out rice for something else?
Totally! Swap in cauliflower rice or quinoa if that's more your vibe, or if you want to skip the grains.
- → Do I have to cook the rice before tossing it in?
Nope! Just rinse the brown rice and throw it straight in. It'll soak up all the flavors while it cooks.
- → Does this freeze well?
Definitely. Let it cool all the way down, pop it in airtight containers, and stash it in the freezer for up to 3 months.
- → How do I get that crispy golden cheesy top?
After you top with cheese, slide it under the broiler for a couple of minutes to make things bubbly and golden.
- → What’s good to eat with this dish?
Try it with a crunchy green salad or some warm, crusty bread on the side—it’s a great match.