
This zesty homemade tomato spread turns basic roma tomatoes into a flexible topping that'll completely change your sandwich game and appetizer platters. I stumbled on this method during last year's tomato harvest, and now it's my go-to trick for boosting everyday meals without much work.
I originally whipped this tomato spread up when my garden was bursting with tomatoes and I couldn't face another batch of sauce. These days my relatives ask for jars as presents, and I always stash some in my fridge for last-minute cheese boards.
What You'll Need
- Fresh roma tomatoes: these fleshy tomatoes contain less water and pack more flavor when cooked down
- Brown sugar: creates rich caramel sweetness that cuts through tomato sharpness
- Fresh grated ginger: brings a snappy heat that lifts the whole mixture
- Apple cider vinegar: helps it last longer while adding nice tang
- Ground cinnamon: adds cozy depth and rounds out the flavors
- Ground cumin: gives savory, earthy background notes
- Red pepper flakes: adds subtle warmth that slowly builds without being too much
- Salt: totally needed to pull all tastes together perfectly
How To Make It
- Mix Everything:
- Throw all your stuff into a big dutch oven or thick-bottomed pot. The thicker your pot, the less chance your jam will burn during the long cooking time. Just chop those tomatoes roughly but try to keep the pieces similar sized so they cook evenly.
- Heat It Up:
- Put it on medium-high until you get a proper bubbling boil. The tomatoes start giving off juice right away, making it look soupy at first. This step wakes up all the flavors and gets them mingling together.
- Cook Slowly:
- Turn down the heat so it just bubbles softly and let it go for 2-3 hours. This long cook time lets water escape while concentrating flavors and creating that perfect jam texture. Give it a stir often, especially toward the end, so it won't stick and burn.
- Check If It's Ready:
- Your jam is done when most liquid's gone, leaving something thick you can spread. Run a wooden spoon through the middle—the jam should fill in slowly, kind of like thick ketchup. You'll notice it's turned a deep reddish-brown color.
- Let It Rest:
- Let it cool all the way down to room temp before putting it in containers. The jam gets a bit thicker as it cools, settling into its final texture and letting all those flavors fully blend together.

The real star in this recipe has to be the fresh grated ginger. I found out how crucial it was when I once tried using powder instead and missed that bright zingy kick. My mother-in-law now bugs me to bring a jar whenever we stop by—she swears it makes her grilled cheese taste like it's from a fancy café.
Ways To Enjoy It
Turn this tomato spread into a wow-worthy starter by adding it to a cheese tray. It works magic next to creamy brie, bold cheddar, or tart goat cheese. Throw in some crackers, sliced bread, and a handful of nuts for a simple but fancy spread that'll impress company without much fuss.
For regular meals, swap this jam in wherever you'd use ketchup. It adds rich flavor to hamburgers, grilled cheese, or even morning eggs. Its sweet-savory mix works great with fatty foods, cutting through richness with its balanced tartness.

Great Matches
While this spread tastes amazing by itself, certain food friends really make it shine. Try it on toast with avocado and a runny egg for breakfast. At lunch, spread it on turkey and brie for a fancy sandwich. For dinner, drop a spoonful next to grilled meats as a quick sauce that brightens the whole plate.
The jam also works wonders as a coating for roasted meats. Brush some on chicken thighs or pork loin just before they finish cooking for a shiny, tasty finish that turns golden brown in the oven.
Fixing Common Problems
If your jam looks too runny after cooking for the suggested time, just keep it simmering uncovered until it thickens up how you want. Roma tomatoes usually have less juice, but wetter types might need extra cooking time.
For jam that got too thick or dark, just add a bit of water or more vinegar to thin it out. Keep in mind that your jam will get thicker as it cools down, so aim for something a little runnier than what you ultimately want.
Common Recipe Questions
- → What type of tomatoes is best for this jam?
Ripe roma tomatoes are ideal because they contain less juice and offer a naturally sweeter taste.
- → How long does the jam need to cook?
You'll want to simmer the mix for about 2-3 hours, giving it a stir now and then, until you get that thick, jam-like texture.
- → How should I store the finished jam?
Keep it in your fridge for up to 2 weeks, pop it in the freezer for 4 months, or can it properly to store in your pantry for a year.
- → What can I pair this jam with?
Try it on hamburgers, inside sandwiches, next to cheese and crackers, or use it instead of regular ketchup.
- → Can I adjust the spice level?
Absolutely, just add fewer or more red pepper flakes depending on how spicy you want it.