Save Pin
Tender beef meatballs loaded up with gooey mozzarella centers and slow-cooked in a tasty, garlicky marinara always remind me of cozy Italian comfort food. The cheesy surprise inside makes any pasta night way more fun. This is what I whip up when everyone's hungry and I need something guaranteed to make people smile—it's awesome for make-ahead meals or just a relaxing Sunday table.
The first night I made these, the family cheered when they saw the cheese bubbling out of the middle. Honestly, I've started doubling up every time so we have extras stashed away for the crazy nights.
Irresistible Ingredients
- Marinara sauce: Cozy, full-flavored tomato sauce is the perfect home for these meatballs Pick your favorite kind—jarred or homemade, just make sure it’s bright and herby
- Olive oil: Use it for getting a nice sear on your meatballs and to bump up richness Fruity extra virgin makes a difference
- Fresh mozzarella cheese: The melty heart of these Just get the good stuff for that stretchy factor
- Salt and black pepper, freshly ground: They pull the flavors together Taste your mix as you go for perfect balance
- Dried oregano and basil: Two classic herbs that bring all those Italian flavors Check that they pack a punch—not dusty or old
- Parmesan cheese: Finely grate it in for a salty, rich finish Parmesan makes everything better
- Panko breadcrumbs: Keeps the meatballs airy and juicy Unseasoned is best for texture
- Fresh parsley: Chop this at the last minute for brightness Both goes in the mix and for topping
- Garlic cloves: Mince for deep flavor and zing Use fresh garlic for that strong but mellow kick
- Small onion: Give it a fine chop for sweetness and body Pick a solid, clean one
- Large egg: This is your glue, so everything holds together Use a good, fresh egg
- Ground beef: For best flavor and juiciness, snag beef that’s close to 85% lean
- Parmesan cheese and parsley, extra: Sprinkle on top at the end for added freshness and more cheesy goodness
Simple Step Guide
- Garnish and Serve:
- Chop up some parsley and grate extra parmesan Sprinkle them over the saucy meatballs right before bringing them to the table—it gives a pop of flavor and color
- Simmer in Sauce:
- Add your browned meatballs back to the pan and pour over plenty of marinara Drop the heat so everything gently bubbles Cover and cook for about ten minutes, flipping meatballs halfway through
- Check and Enjoy:
- Slide a meatball open to peek—cheese should be gooey and the meat fully cooked No pink at all, and your thermometer reads 160 at the center Spoon onto your favorite pasta and soak up every bit of sauce with bread
- Browning Time:
- Warm up olive oil in a big skillet over medium-high Lay in the meatballs—don’t wedge them together Let them brown all over, about two or three minutes each turn If the skillet’s too full, do a couple rounds
- Stuff and Roll:
- Grab a chunk of the beef mix, press it flat in your palm Make a dent, tuck in a mozzarella square Fold the meat around the cheese and roll into a ball Do this until you’ve got a dozen stuffed little guys
- Cube the Cheese:
- Chop mozzarella into twelve chunks, each about half an inch across Keep these cold until you're ready—makes stuffing simple
- Mix the Base:
- Toss together beef, egg, onion, garlic, parsley, breadcrumbs, parmesan, oregano, basil, salt, and pepper You want everything well blended but not packed tight, or the meatballs could get heavy
Save Pin
Cutting into that meatball for that cheesy pull is totally my favorite bit It’s the kind of comfort that makes me think of chilly nights battling my sister for the longest cheese stretch
Keeping Extras Fresh
Let leftover meatballs cool all the way before popping them into an airtight box in the fridge—they’ll be good for up to three days. For longer, toss ‘em in a freezer bag (sauce or no sauce, your pick) and enjoy within two months. Thaw overnight in the fridge, then warm up slowly on low heat or microwave with a splash of sauce to keep them nice and moist.
Switch Up Your Ingredients
Go lighter by using turkey or chicken instead of beef. Want new cheesy vibes? Swap in provolone or fontina. For a gluten free twist, choose your favorite GF breadcrumbs and they’ll still hold together just right.
Save Pin
How to Serve
Lay these meatballs on top of spaghetti, ziti, whatever pasta you love Best subs ever? Stuff them inside a fresh roll, add an extra scoop of marinara, and let that cheese ooze Pair up with classic garlic bread or a cool Caesar for a meal that works for picky kiddos or when friends pop by
Backstory and Tradition
You’ll find stuffed meatballs in lots of Italian American homes, but their story traces back to southern Italy and Sicily—over there, folks filled meatballs with cheese or egg for ages. Immigrants brought the tradition stateside, adding their own spin. Now, biting into that cheesy middle feels like celebration and comfort all in one.
Common Recipe Questions
- → How can I stop cheese from escaping while cooking?
Make sure you press the beef fully around the cheese, covering every bit and pinching any gaps closed so the mozzarella can’t leak.
- → Is a different cheese okay in the middle?
Definitely! Swap in fontina or provolone for a lovely melt—just stick with firmer cheeses that won’t run out everywhere once they’re hot.
- → How’s the yummiest way to eat these?
Top your favorite pasta with them. Or pile ‘em onto a toasted sub roll, or just dunk with a chunk of bread—the sauce is too good to waste.
- → What about leftovers and reheating?
Tuck them into an airtight box and stash in the fridge for three days, or pop in the freezer. When you’re ready, heat gently in sauce until nice and warm again.
- → Can I prep these ahead of time?
Yep! Form your meatballs and let them chill in the fridge until you’re set to cook. That way, they’re fresh as can be at dinnertime.
- → What’s the safe inside temp for these meatballs?
You just want the very middle to hit 160°F. That means they’re cooked right and safe to eat.