Save Pin
Want an ooey gooey sandwich that gives you all the pizza night feels—without the wait? Pizza Grilled Cheese is your new go-to. Crunchy toasted bread stuffed with stretchy mozzarella, rich tomato sauce, and just enough pepperoni for that tang. Makes for a super easy weeknight bite or a little cheesy treat packed with that classic pizza flavor you love.
The first time I tried these on a gloomy day, the yummy smells lured the whole house before I'd even finished cooking. Now it's my ace for fast family lunches or a quick bite during movie night.
Easy Ingredients
- Pepperoni thinly sliced: packs in a little heat, classic pizza vibes, and meaty, chewy goodness
- Pizza or marinara sauce: pulls everything together with that zesty flavor—go for a simple, fresh-tasting jar
- Shredded mozzarella cheese: melts so well for that stretchy bite—always better if you shred your own
- Sturdy bread: go with thick sourdough or something hearty; skip flimsy bread for the best crunch
- Salt: wakes up all the flavors—kosher works best but use what you've got
- Garlic powder: brings that homey garlic bread vibe—freshness makes a big difference
- Italian seasoning: gives it that pizza shop flavor; Italian brands are especially nice
- Grated parmesan cheese: makes every bite extra savory and gives the bread a great crunch, so grab a good aged piece if you can
- Unsalted butter softened: makes the outside crisp and rich with each bite
Look out for sturdy, fresh bread, mozzarella that's not soggy, and sauce that tastes lively—not flat or bland.
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Kick Things Off: Mix Up the Butter
- Take a little bowl and mash together the softened butter, parmesan, salt, garlic powder, and Italian seasoning. Blend it until the whole thing is creamy—it should be easy to spread and taste cheesy and herby when you're done.
- Stack 'Em Up: Build Your Sandwiches
- Lay down four bread slices and spread pizza or marinara sauce all over. Sprinkle plenty of mozzarella, then pop six slices of pepperoni on each. Top with a second slice of bread—spread side goes in.
- Get the Outside Ready
- Coat the top and bottom of each sandwich with your cheese-butter mix—leave no corner dry for max crunchiness during grilling.
- Time to Grill
- Turn your skillet to medium, then set the sandwiches in butter side down once it's hot. Go three to four minutes per side. Press gently with a spatula and look for a deep golden color and gooey cheese inside.
- Just About There—Slice and Eat
- Transfer sandwiches off the pan and give them a minute or two to cool down. Cut them up and serve right away. Extra sauce on the side for dipping is always a win!
Save Pin
I'm always pumped to use thick-cut rustic bread. It crisps up perfectly and sucks up all that garlicky, cheesy butter. The day my family tried these together, we all ended up making a mess and building our own versions with whatever toppings sounded fun.
How to Keep the Extras Tasty
Pop any leftover grilled cheeses in a sealed container in the fridge. They're best if you eat them in a couple of days. To warm one up, toss it in a skillet on low until it's toasty and hot. I'd avoid the microwave—it just makes them soggy.
Ingredient Switch-Ups
Try dairy-free cheese or just skip pepperoni for a full-on veggie vibe, tossing on extras like spinach, olives, or bell peppers. Use whole wheat bread for more crunch, or swap Italian seasoning for fresh basil or oregano if you have them handy.
Best Ways to Serve
Cut the sandwiches into strips—super fun for dunking at parties. They really shine alongside a fresh salad for a quick meal or dunked into tomato soup when it's chilly. Sometimes I even dice them up as croutons and toss into my Caesar salad for a cheesy kick.
Save Pin
The Story Behind Pizza Grilled Cheese
Pizza grilled cheese is what happens when you mash up two favorites: gooey grilled cheese and that classic American twist on pizza. Not something you'd find in Italy, but mixing these up is an American thing for sure. You get all the best flavors at once, and it's perfect for folks who loved both growing up.
Common Recipe Questions
- → Which bread should I pick for these grilled cheese sandwiches?
Go for something sturdy like Italian or sourdough. It holds its own and gives you that perfect crunchy outside without falling apart.
- → Is it possible to make a meatless version?
Definitely! Leave out the pepperoni or swap in your favorite plant-based slices. There’s already tons of tasty cheese flavor, so you won’t even miss the meat.
- → What kind of cheese gives the best melt?
Mozzarella melts super smooth and stretchy, but don’t hesitate to toss in provolone or a little cheddar if you want a twist on the flavor.
- → How do I make sure my sandwiches stay crispy, not soggy?
Keep the sauce layer thin and use thick bread. Toast up both sides of your sandwich until it’s golden and crunchy all the way through.
- → What extras can I toss in for more punch?
Slice up some mushrooms, throw in olives or bell peppers, or sprinkle in some red pepper flakes if you want heat. Fresh basil sprigs will brighten things up, too.
- → Are these easy enough for someone new in the kitchen?
You bet! With hardly any prepping, simple layered steps, and easy skillet cooking, just about anyone can whip these up in no time. Perfect for beginners.