Save Pin
These old-world Italian holiday cookies turn basic kitchen staples into a cherished Christmas custom. With their tender, rich texture and topped with sweet icing and colorful sprinkles, they've been central to Italian family holiday parties for years, bringing smiles to family meetups and treat swaps everywhere.
I first picked up this recipe standing next to my Italian nonna, and nowadays my family asks for them every Christmas season. When they're cooking, the house gets filled with vanilla's sweet smell, telling everyone the holidays are coming soon.
Ingredients
- Eggs: Brought to room temp for smoother mixing and fluffier cookie texture
- Granulated sugar: Adds the ideal amount of sweetness while keeping the gentle flavor intact
- Unsalted butter: Let it soften naturally for that wonderful melt-away feeling
- Vanilla extract: Brings comfort and depth though you can swap in almond extract for something more nutty
- All-purpose flour: Forms the base while keeping cookies soft
- Baking powder: Creates that signature pillowy lift
- Powdered sugar: Whips up into a silky coating that sets nicely
- Nonpareil sprinkles: Bring holiday cheer and tiny bits of crunch
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Mix the Dry Stuff:
- Stir flour and baking powder together until they're fully mixed. This way the baking powder gets spread out in all the dough, so your cookies rise evenly.
- Start Your Mixture:
- Beat the butter, vanilla extract, and sugar in a big bowl until it looks pale and fluffy. This step puts air bubbles in the mix, which makes your cookies turn out soft. Don't rush—beat for about 3 minutes.
- Put in the Eggs:
- Drop in eggs one by one, mixing completely after each. Going slow stops the mix from separating and keeps everything smooth. Make sure each egg disappears into the batter before adding another.
- Join Everything Together:
- Pour the flour mix into your wet stuff and stir just until it comes together. Your dough should feel soft but not fall apart. Don't mix too much or your cookies will turn tough.
- Work and Cool:
- Lightly knead until the dough feels firm but not sticky, adding tiny sprinkles of flour if needed. Wrap it in plastic and stick it in the fridge for an hour. This break lets the flour soak up moisture and the butter get firm, making the dough easier to handle.
- Form with Patience:
- Make your chosen shapes, either simple 1-inch balls or classic curls. For curls, roll bits into 6-inch snakes on a lightly floured counter, then twist them into spirals. Set them on paper-lined cookie sheets with 2 inches between them.
- Cook Just Right:
- Bake at 375°F for 8 to 10 minutes. Look for slight browning on the bottoms while tops stay white. This gentle baking keeps the cookies tender inside.
- Let Them Rest:
- Move baked cookies to a cooling rack and let them get completely cold before adding glaze. If you rush, the glaze will just slide off warm cookies.
- Top Them Off:
- Make glaze by mixing powdered sugar, vanilla extract, and milk till smooth. Dip the tops of cold cookies into it, letting extra drip away. Quickly add sprinkles before the glaze hardens.
Save Pin
Vanilla extract really brings these cookies to life. My nonna always tossed in a bit more than called for, saying that was why her cookies were the first to vanish at family parties. That little extra touch has become our special family custom.
How To Keep Them Fresh
These Italian holiday cookies stay soft and tasty when kept in a sealed container at room temp. They'll be good for about a week, though at my house they're usually gone in three days flat. If you're storing them longer, put parchment paper between layers so they don't stick together. For keeping them many weeks, freeze the cookies without glaze, then thaw and decorate when you're ready to eat them.
Save Pin
Tasty Twists
This dough works great for lots of yummy changes. Try adding some lemon or orange zest to brighten up the flavor. If you love chocolate, mix in tiny chocolate chips or drizzle melted chocolate on top instead of the usual glaze. You can also throw in finely chopped pistachios or almonds for extra crunch and taste. During Christmas time, a dash of anise extract makes them truly Italian and goes great with after-dinner coffee.
What To Serve With Them
These cookies go wonderfully with holiday drinks. Try them with a hot espresso or cappuccino for a real Italian feel. They taste amazing with hot cocoa topped with whipped cream because they aren't too sweet themselves. Grown-ups might enjoy them with a small glass of Vin Santo wine or some amaretto. They also look great on a dessert plate with fresh fruit and soft Italian cheeses like mascarpone when you want to impress your holiday guests.
Their Rich History
In Italian culture, Christmas cookies like these stand for joy and plenty. Called "biscotti di Natale" in Italy, they started in southern areas where families would get together before Christmas to make big batches. The colorful sprinkles show happiness and celebration, while sharing cookies builds community ties. In many Italian American homes, grandparents, parents and kids make these cookies together, passing down family secrets and stories. Their simple but pretty look shows how Italians value both beauty and usefulness in their food traditions.
Common Recipe Questions
- → What type of flour is best for these cookies?
Regular all-purpose flour works best for these cookies as it gives the right body and smoothness for a tender, rich outcome.
- → Can I substitute almond extract for vanilla?
Absolutely, almond extract adds a wonderful nutty and fragrant touch to these cookies. You can even try half vanilla and half almond for a unique flavor.
- → How long should I chill the dough?
Cover the dough with plastic wrap and let it rest in the fridge for at least 1 hour. This makes handling much easier and helps the cookies keep their shape while they bake.
- → Can I freeze these cookies?
You can definitely freeze the baked cookies for up to 3 months. They'll stay fresher if you freeze them plain and add the icing and decorations after thawing. Just let them come to room temperature before finishing.
- → How can I ensure the glaze has the right consistency?
For a glaze that's thick but pourable, mix powdered sugar, milk, and vanilla until it's smooth. If it seems too thick, add a few drops of milk. If it's running too much, sprinkle in more powdered sugar.