Save Pin
Whenever I'm heading to a get-together or planning a chill holiday hangout, these little pineapple upside-down cheesecakes are my favorite thing to bring. They're tangy and creamy, like sunshine in each bite, plus they're easy to swipe off the platter—everyone raves about their tropical charm.
I brought these to my family’s cookout once and couldn’t even set the tray down before folks grabbed them all. Now, every casual party feels incomplete if I don’t show up with these treats.
Irresistible Ingredients
- Caramel sauce: It brings a buttery flavor boost that plays up all the tropical feels. Use a thicker sauce so it doesn’t just run everywhere
- Pineapple chunks: Sweet pineapple makes every bite sunny. Make sure to press out extra juice on a paper towel so your cakes don’t go soggy
- Vanilla extract: Adds that cozy aroma and brings the flavors together. If you can, use real vanilla for the best taste
- Large eggs: Eggs bind your batter and help the cheesecakes set just right. Fresh is best, makes a difference
- Granulated sugar: Sweetness comes from this—fine white sugar mixes in easiest
- Cream cheese: Go for full-fat for dreamy smoothness. Let it sit at room temp for an hour before mixing so it gets creamy, not clumpy
- Melted butter: The key for making the crust stick together well. Melt it right before you mix so it blends perfectly
- Graham cracker crumbs: These are the base and stay light and crisp, not dense. Homemade crumbs taste extra fresh
Easy Step-by-Step
- Chill and finish up:
- Once completely cool in the tray, move to the fridge and chill at least four hours, or overnight. Before you serve, douse with caramel on top. A cherry or mint on top is totally optional but looks great
- Bake:
- Pop your muffin tin into the oven for about twenty to twenty-five minutes. You want edges to firm up but centers should look a little jiggly. Don’t rush pulling them from the pan—let them cool there all the way
- Assemble your cups:
- Ladle the cheesecake filling into each spot, leaving a little space at the top. Lay pineapple on each, pressing gently so they don’t sink down too far
- Mix up the filling:
- Grab a big bowl, beat the softened cream cheese and sugar together so it’s smooth. Drop in the eggs one by one, mixing between each. Stir in enough vanilla to really bring out the flavor
- Make your crust:
- Dump those graham crumbs and melted butter in a bowl, mix up till it’s like wet sand. Spoon into your lined muffin tin, press down tight using a spoon or the bottom of a glass so the base stays put
- Get your oven going:
- Heat your oven to 350°F (175°C). Line your muffin pan with paper liners to keep cleanup and removal super easy
Save Pin
The caramel totally pulls these all together—my niece calls it the “golden touch.” My crew goes wild for extra caramel and pineapple on the side for dipping too.
Best Way to Keep Them
Tuck leftover cheesecakes into a sealed container and stash in the fridge. They’re tastiest for about four days. Want to prep super early? Freeze them before adding caramel, and thaw in the fridge when you’re set to serve
Quick Ingredient Alternatives
Out of graham crackers? Crushed vanilla wafers or digestive cookies work well instead. Switch to low-fat cream cheese for something lighter (though the filling feels a little different). Grab a fresh pineapple for the boldest taste—just chop it up and dry it really well first
Save Pin
Fun Ways to Serve
Put your mini cheesecakes on a pretty tray, scatter toasted coconut for crunch and looks. A spoon of whipped cream on top makes them feel extra luxe. For a true tropical scene, add fresh berries or kiwi slices to the platter
Tradition Meets Modern
This dish is inspired by old-school American pineapple upside-down cakes, but here it’s bite-sized and easy to pass around. The bright flavors always make me remember big summer parties with family. The small size means you can share them all around
Common Recipe Questions
- → What stops the crust from getting mushy?
Dry the pineapple pieces really well before putting them on your cheesecakes. Wet pineapple will mess with the texture and make things soggy.
- → Can I swap out canned pineapple for fresh?
For sure—chop up fresh pineapple into little pieces, squeeze out extra juice, and you’re good to go. Less juice means a better result.
- → What’s the best way to make the crust firm?
Smoosh down the buttery graham mixture in your cupcake cups so it’s nice and tight. That way, the creamy part sits right on top and doesn’t fall apart.
- → How can I keep the tops from cracking?
Only stir the batter until it looks smooth. Don’t go crazy mixing! Popping a pan of water in the oven (not under the cakes, just nearby) adds some helpful steam so cracks stay away.
- → How long do these need to chill for best texture?
They like at least four hours in the fridge, or just leave them overnight. That way, they set up all the way and turn out smooth.
- → Can I dress these up with something extra?
Why not! Add a cherry or a couple mint leaves for a splash of color right before you dig in.