Save Pin
I'm always turning to these easy cheesecake parfaits when friends show up out of the blue. Creamy cheesecake filling, sweet cherry layer, and buttery graham cracker crumbs all stacked in cups—you’d swear it took forever, but you’ll be done in no time. They look super fancy, but trust me, it’s all about the simple steps.
I started making these parfaits after my oven went out right before a surprise birthday bash. They were such a hit that everyone begged me for directions before leaving, and now my family asks for them again and again.
Dreamy Ingredients
- Cherry pie filling: Gives a bold pop of sweet-tart flavor and vibrant color—use a top-notch brand if you can
- Vanilla extract: Rounds out all the flavors—real vanilla is best here
- Lemon juice: Brings brightness and helps firm up the filling naturally
- Sweetened condensed milk: Adds sweetness and a silky feel, so you don’t need extra sugar
- Cream cheese: Is what makes the filling rich and smooth; don’t skip letting it soften first
- Butter: Holds the cracker crumbs together, and adds a tasty richness—go unsalted for best results
- Granulated sugar: Sweetens up the crust layer just enough
- Graham cracker crumbs: Crunchy base that holds up best when made fresh
Simple Instructions
- Finish It Up:
- Spoon the rest of the cherry topping over each parfait, then sprinkle with extra graham crumbs for a final crunch and pretty look.
- Wrap Up Layers:
- Spread the leftover cheesecake filling on top, smoothing gently so the layers stay even and keep that neat look.
- Keep Layering:
- Drop more graham crumbs over the cherries in each cup, keeping that parfait pattern going.
- Add Cherry Goodness:
- Scoop half the cherry pie topping on top of the cheesecake layer—make sure every cup gets some fruit and syrup for the color and taste.
- First Cracker-Coated Layer:
- Add two spoonfuls of crumb mixture into six plastic cups and press a little with a spoon’s back for a flat bottom. Next, layer on three spoonfuls of the cheesecake filling, keeping it level.
- Stir in Extras:
- Mix in the lemon juice and vanilla with your cream cheese blend. The lemon not only gives a pop of flavor, but it also magically thickens your filling.
- Make the Cheesecake Cream:
- Whip up the softened cream cheese in a bowl for a couple of minutes until it’s completely smooth. Slowly pour in the condensed milk while mixing until it turns thick and creamy, but still easy to spoon.
- Put Together Crust:
- In a little bowl, stir up graham crumbs, sugar, and melted butter until the mix just sticks together—crumbly but not dry. This adds bite to your parfaits.
Save Pin
Cream cheese is the real star here. I noticed if you let it come to room temp before mixing, there’s never a lump. My grandma swore by this for that extra-smooth, creamy feel—and she was totally right.
Plan Ahead Hacks
Honestly, the flavor gets even better as these sit in the fridge. Put them together at least two hours early so everything blends just right—if you can, up to a day ahead is even better. The crumb layers will soften a bit but still keep that nice chewy bite next to the creamy filling.
Fun Twists
Though I always go cherry, you can get creative. Try blueberry topping for a fresh look and soft finish, or peach with a touch of cinnamon to give your graham crumbs a kick. Lemon lovers can use lemon fruit topping for a zingy treat—super nice on a hot day. Got homemade stewed fruit? That works great, too, for a rich and less sugary taste.
Save Pin
How to Serve
They’re gorgeous right out of the cup, but if you want to show off, add whipped cream and a sprig of mint. For a fancier vibe, swap into clear dessert glasses or wine goblets to show the pretty layers. They’re awesome with coffee or sweet wine as a chill finish to your meal. Or go wild—set up a toppings bar with whipped cream, chocolate curls, or extra fruit so everyone can style theirs exactly how they like.
Keeping Them Fresh
Just cover with cling wrap and chill them up to three days—they actually taste even better after sitting overnight, since the layers blend a little more. Freezing? Wouldn’t suggest it—the texture doesn’t come back right. If you want to prep even earlier, make each part separately, then assemble them a day before you plan to eat.
Common Recipe Questions
- → Can I swap out the cherries for something else?
Of course! Go with lemon, peach, blueberry, or any fruit filling that sounds good to you for a spin on the classic.
- → How long do these parfaits keep in the fridge?
Just cover and chill them—they’ll stay yummy and fresh for up to three days in the fridge.
- → Got any ideas if I don’t want to use graham crackers?
Definitely! Swap in some crushed Oreos, digestive cookies, or any cookies you love for a fun new crunch.
- → How do I whip up homemade whipped cream?
Pour some cold heavy cream in a bowl with sugar and a bit of vanilla, then beat it until it holds its shape.
- → Stuck without lemon juice—what now?
Lime juice totally works here too. It gives your filling that needed tang and helps it thicken.