Save Pin
Strawberry Shortcake Sugar Cookies are my favorite way to jazz up a gloomy winter or put something special into a holiday cookie box. Turning a plain sugar cookie into these pretty, crumbly homemade treats is pretty simple. That glossy drizzle and the crisp strawberry topping really take it up a notch. Every bite is like munching right into the unforgettable part of strawberry shortcake, but tiny and perfect for your hands.
My niece once asked for a pink snack for Valentine’s and that got me hooked on these. Now I bake them for birthdays, picnics, basically anywhere because the smiles when folks see them are priceless.
Irresistible Ingredients
- Strawberry shortcake crumbs: sweet, tangy crunch comes in at the end—choose those that have real dried strawberries
- Pink food coloring: a bright pop of color, gels keep it bold without thinning your glaze
- Milk: helps loosen glaze, whole milk keeps it creamy
- Confectioner's sugar: super smooth glaze owes it all here—sifting stops any lumps
- Baking powder: gets dough to puff just right, check that yours is fresh
- Salt: cuts the sugar and makes the flavors deeper—a sprinkle of sea salt is my go-to
- All-purpose flour: makes for that perfect soft chew, sift for extra-light cookies
- Vanilla extract: adds that sweet-toasty scent, real vanilla is worth it
- Large eggs: keep things moist and all together, grab the freshest you can find
- Granulated sugar: all the sweet without weighing down the dough, fine sugar mixes best
- Softened butter: makes cookies soft and rich—good butter is key
Easy-Peasy Steps
- Decorate and Finish
- Zigzag both pink and white glaze onto cooled cookies using a snipped zip bag for control. Quickly sprinkle over those tasty shortcake bits so they stick well. Let 'em harden before you stack or give them away.
- Make Glaze and Color
- Mix milk into sifted powdered sugar until nice and smooth. Pour half in a second bowl, drop in food coloring for the pink. Start with just a little—it goes a long way for bright icing.
- Bake and Cool
- Bake in a hot 350 oven just 10 minutes, watching for pale edges, not brown tops. Leave on the tray to set for a couple minutes, then pop onto a rack until cool.
- Shape and Flatten Dough
- Scoop dough with a big spoon and roll into balls. Set them onto a baking tray and squish flat with the bottom of a cup so they're a little over a quarter inch thick. You’ll get even baking this way.
- Combine Dry Ingredients
- Sift your flour, baking powder, and salt straight into the wet base. Gently fold together until just mixed—if you stir too much, cookies get tough.
- Add Eggs and Vanilla
- Crack your eggs in one at a time, mixing after each. Splash in the vanilla and beat until it smells amazing and the batter looks blended.
- Cream the Butter and Sugar
- With a hand mixer, beat butter and sugar together on medium about four minutes until fluffy. This gives you that soft cookie texture everyone loves.
Save Pin
Best part? That first swoosh of glaze and clatter of crumbs. I still laugh thinking of baking these with my cousins, spoons flying, pink drizzle hitting the counter, and everyone grinning as we finished off the extras.
Keep 'Em Fresh Tips
Seal cookies in a single layer in something airtight on the counter for up to four days. Stack 'em only if you pop parchment between layers to keep toppings neat. Freeze plain cookies unfrosted—just thaw and decorate right before serving for max crunch and softness.
Ingredient Swaps
Try almond extract instead of vanilla if you want nuts in the background. Dairy-free butter and lactose-free milk work great too. Out of strawberry crumbs? Smash some freeze-dried berries with a crunchy vanilla cookie to get a similar effect.
Fun Ways To Serve
Put them out with tea or at a wedding shower for a sweet touch. Lay out fresh berries if you want it to taste even more like summer. Throw a decorating party for kids and let them go wild with their own cookies and sprinkles.
Save Pin
Connected History
Strawberry shortcake goes all the way back to 1840s North America as a party dessert. These cookies keep those flavors alive but make them easy for get-togethers—classic taste, grab-and-go style.
Common Recipe Questions
- → How do I get a soft, tender texture?
Whip up your butter and sugar super well so it’s extra light, and pull your cookies out of the oven while they’re still a bit soft.
- → Can I use store-bought shortcake crumbs?
You sure can. Store-bought ones work, but homemade is crunchier and has more flavor.
- → Do the cookies need to be cooled before glazing?
Yep, let your cookies cool all the way so your glaze doesn’t just slide off.
- → What's the best way to apply the glaze?
Grab a plastic bag, snip off a corner or use a piping bag, and drizzle away for those fun stripes.
- → How should I store these cookies?
Wait until the glaze sets, then pop them in an airtight box to keep them tasting fresh.
- → Can food coloring be omitted?
Totally—skip the food coloring or pick a natural option if that’s what you like.