Save Pin
Bite-sized pizza muffins have all your favorite pizza flavors jammed into a muffin tin. Think gooey cheese, layers of pepperoni, and a crazy comforting texture. They're awesome for feeding a hungry crowd at a party, or pulling together a fast dinner that everyone, from kids to grownups, will ask for again.
The first time I baked these was for my kid's birthday bash. They were the first snack gone, even before anyone touched the chips. Now my family begs for these muffin pizzas every game night.
Tasty Ingredients
- All purpose flour: keeps these muffins sturdy and helps them keep their shape For best results, fluff it up before scooping and use fresh flour
- Baking powder: makes the muffins puff up and stay soft Be sure it hasn’t expired so your muffins don’t end up heavy
- Dried oregano: gives you that signature pizza flavor Pick the most fragrant one you can
- Garlic powder: makes each bite taste savory Fresh garlic is too strong here but powder hits just right
- Black pepper and salt: round out the flavors nicely Kosher salt gives a cleaner taste
- Eggs (large): bind everything and bring richness Crack them in a cup first to avoid shell surprises
- Whole milk: keeps everything moist and fluffy Full fat works best for texture and taste
- Olive oil: adds a touch of moisture and a mild fruity finish Extra virgin gives more flavor depth
- Pizza sauce: gives a tangy hit and keeps the muffins juicy Thick sauce works best so it won’t water down your batter
- Mini pepperoni: old-school pizza flavor in a small bite Look for ones that aren’t greasy and have a bright red color
- Shredded mozzarella: brings that classic pull-apart cheesiness Use whole milk mozzarella and shred your own for super melty goodness
- Parmesan cheese, grated: boosts flavor and adds a nice salty kick Try to grate fresh from the block
- Mozzarella cubes: go right in the center to melt into a gooey surprise Make sure every piece is the same size for even cheesiness
Simple How-To Steps
- Let 'em Cool:
- Wait five minutes so the cheese settles. Pop them out with a spatula and serve warm. Dunk them in extra sauce if you want for dipping.
- Crumble Toppings and Bake:
- Sprinkle the last bit of mozzarella and pepperoni on each cup so they bake up cheesy and loaded with flavor. Slide the tray into the hot oven (middle rack) for fifteen to eighteen minutes, till you see bubbly cheese and golden tops.
- Fill Muffin Tin:
- Spoon the batter into your greased muffin tin about halfway. Stick a mozzarella cube in the middle and press down gently. Cover that up with more batter so the cheese is hidden.
- Mix Cheeses and Pepperoni In:
- Fold in most of your mozzarella, the Parmesan, and nearly all the pepperoni. Leave a bit of both cheese and pepperoni aside for topping later. Don’t worry if the batter is pretty thick.
- Stir Batter Together:
- Pour the wet mix into your dry bowl. Use a spatula and stop mixing as soon as the flour is gone so everything stays soft. Overmixing makes them tough.
- Whisk Up Wet Mix:
- In a new bowl, whisk up your eggs, pizza sauce, olive oil, and milk until it’s all blended and just a little orange from the sauce.
- Combine Dry Ingredients:
- Whisk your flour with garlic powder, baking powder, oregano, salt, and pepper together so the baking powder spreads out and you get an even rise.
- Get Oven and Pan Ready:
- Switch on your oven to three seventy five. Give a twelve cup muffin tin a coat of nonstick spray or oil so things don’t stick. A little paper towel with oil also does the trick fast.
Save Pin
The best part for me is tucking a mozzarella cube right inside the batter. It turns gooey as it bakes and every bite is warm and melty. My kids always crack up when they find that cheesy surprise in the middle.
Keeping Them Fresh
Pop any extras in a closed container for up to three days. If you want the tops to stay a bit crunchy, just crack the lid a little. Warm them back up for five minutes in a toaster oven or regular oven and the cheese will go melty again.
Swap Options
Switch up the flavor by adding cooked sausage or mushrooms instead of pepperoni. For a meat-free version, go with chopped olives, roasted peppers, and meltable plant cheese.
Serving Ideas
Pair pizza muffins with a crunchy Caesar or mixed greens salad. They’re tasty with pizza sauce, ranch, or garlicky yogurt dip on the side. When you’re feeding a bunch of folks, put out several sauces so everyone gets what they like.
Save Pin
Fun Food History
The idea to make pizza in a muffin pan comes from America, where folks love super easy, fun-to-eat snacks. Turning pizza into these tiny hand-held bites means you can serve them fast and people love the fresh twist on classic flavor.
Common Recipe Questions
- → Got a cheese rec for extra melty centers?
Mozzarella shreds melt like a dream, and popping a mozzarella cube inside each one makes it extra oozy. A sprinkle of Parmesan finishes things with a savory kick.
- → Will regular pepperoni work if I don't have mini?
No worries! Just chop up big pepperoni slices so you get little bits in every bite for even flavor.
- → How do I get more flavor on top?
Give 'em a brush of garlic butter right out of the oven and you’ll get a warm, tasty finish that smells amazing.
- → Can I prep these ahead of time?
Absolutely! Keep them in a sealed container once cooled and pop them back in the oven to warm up when you’re ready to eat. They’ll taste just as good.
- → What’s the best dip for these bites?
Classic pizza or marinara sauce is always a hit, but folks love dunking them in ranch, too.